Why your garage floor coating peeled
Coatings almost never fail because of the product. They fail because of what happened, or did not happen, in the two hours before the product went down.

The floor did not fail. The bond did
When a garage floor coating lifts, people usually describe it as the paint peeling. That is understandable and it is the wrong mental model, because it points you at the product when the problem is almost always underneath it.
A coating does not stick to concrete the way paint sticks to a wall. It has to key into the concrete mechanically, which means the surface has to be opened up first so the material can flow into the pore structure and lock there. Get that right and the coating and the slab behave as one thing. Get it wrong and you have a film sitting on top of a smooth surface, held on by very little, waiting for something to pull it off.
In a Pennsylvania garage that something arrives every November. Road salt, freeze and thaw, and a hot tyre parking on the same patch every night.
Failure one: the slab was never ground
This is the big one and it accounts for most of the calls we take.
Preparation has to be mechanical. Diamond grinders take the top layer off the concrete and leave an open, clean, slightly rough profile for the coating to grip. There is no substitute for it and there is no shortcut to it. It is dusty, slow, physical work and it is the single largest cost in a properly built floor.
The shortcut is acid etching, sometimes sold as a professional process, or a pressure wash and a degreaser. Both leave a surface that looks clean and prepared and is neither. Etching can raise a slight texture on some slabs and does nothing at all on hard trowelled ones, which is most modern garage floors. Pressure washing just makes the smooth surface wet.
If your floor came off in large sheets that you could pick up and flex, and the underside of those sheets is smooth and clean like the top of the concrete, that is what happened. The coating never bonded. It was a skin.
Peel a failed sheet over and look at the underside. Smooth and clean means it never bonded. Concrete stuck to it means something else went wrong.
Failure two: moisture pushed it off
The second cause looks different and it is worth learning to tell apart, because the fix is not the same.
Concrete is porous, and water moves up through a slab as vapour whether you can see it or not. A slab poured without a plastic vapour barrier underneath, which describes a great many older Berks County garages and almost every pre war basement, will pass a steady amount of moisture upward forever.
Seal the top of that with a coating and the vapour has nowhere to go. Pressure builds underneath the film and eventually lifts it, usually in blisters or in irregular patches rather than in clean sheets, and often in the middle of the floor rather than at the edges. Turn over a piece and there is frequently a light dusty residue on the underside where the moisture brought salts up with it.
This one is not fixed by grinding harder. It needs a moisture reading first, then a moisture tolerant primer specified to the number, and occasionally the honest answer that a drainage problem needs solving before any coating makes sense.

Failure three: there was not enough material on the floor
The third cause is the simplest. There was not much there to begin with.
A consumer kit from a big box store contains a small volume of high water content material designed to be rolled thin over a large area. Even applied perfectly to a perfectly prepared slab, the finished film is a fraction of the thickness of a professional system. It has very little to give when a tyre twists on it or a jack stand digs in.
You can usually spot this one because the failure is wear rather than release. The coating has not lifted, it has worn through in the traffic lane and around the door, exposing grey concrete in the shape of where the car goes.
This is the least dramatic failure and in some ways the most annoying, because the floor is still stuck down and still has to come off.
Why coating over the old one does not work
The question that comes next is always the same, and it is a reasonable one. Can you not just go over the top of it?
No, and the reason is arithmetic rather than opinion. A new coating laid over an old one is only as attached to the slab as the old one is. Your existing coating has already proved how attached it is, which is not very. Put a new system on top and you have bonded a good floor to a bad one, and the whole assembly comes off together, usually faster than the first one did because it is now heavier.
So everything comes off. Loose material gets scraped, and whatever is still holding on gets ground or shot blasted through. That is slower and harder on equipment than opening up bare concrete, which is exactly why a strip and rebuild honestly costs more than coating a fresh slab.
If somebody quotes you less to go over a failing floor than to do a new one, they are planning to sell you the same failure again with a different colour on it.
Which one do I have
Comes off in flexible sheets, smooth clean underside: preparation. The slab was never ground.
Blisters or irregular patches, often mid floor, dusty residue underneath: moisture.
Worn through to grey in the traffic lane, still stuck elsewhere: thin material.
All three at once is also common, particularly on a kit applied to an older slab.
What we find once it is off
Stripping a failed floor almost always turns up damage nobody knew about, and it is worth being mentally prepared for that rather than surprised by it.
Coatings hide things. Spalling that the film was holding together, cracks that were painted over rather than repaired, and delaminated patches around the overhead door where salt water has been getting under the edge for years. None of it is a disaster and all of it needs doing.
We fill and level all of it as part of the job, and you get told what we found rather than having it quietly disappear under the new coating. That is the same reason customers keep mentioning prep work in the reviews. When the person who quoted the job is the person holding the grinder, there is nobody to hide the findings from.
What the rebuild actually is
Once we are back to clean concrete the job becomes a normal build, and it runs the same way every one of ours does.
The slab gets diamond ground with dust extraction until the surface is uniformly open. Cracks, divots and pitting get cut back where they need it, filled and levelled. Where the moisture reading calls for it, a moisture tolerant primer goes down first.
Then an American made base coat, with flake broadcast into it by hand until the wet surface will not take another handful. The next day the excess chip is scraped and vacuumed back, which is the step that turns a rough surface into an even one, and a polyaspartic topcoat seals the whole system in.
Residential interior floors carry a true lifetime warranty against the system failing. We can offer that because of the first stage, not the last one.
The honest exception
There is one case where we will tell you not to do it, and it comes up a few times a year.
If the slab itself is failing rather than the surface, a coating is cosmetics over a structural problem. A garage floor that has heaved, dropped at one corner, or cracked right through with the two sides sitting at different heights is moving. Anything laid on top of it will crack along the same line, probably in the first year.
That conversation occasionally costs us the job, and we have it anyway. It has never once cost us a warranty claim.
What a proper quote should tell you
If you are getting a floor rebuilt after a failure, there are four things a quote should state plainly. If they are missing, ask.
How the slab is being prepared. The word you want is grind, not etch, not clean, not prep. Diamond grinding with dust extraction, back to open concrete.
What happens to the existing coating. It should say removal, and the price should reflect that this is slower than working on bare concrete.
Whether the slab is being moisture tested, and what happens if the number comes back high. A quote that does not mention moisture on a basement or an older garage has not thought about it.
What the topcoat is and how thick the system is overall. Full broadcast flake under polyaspartic is a very different floor to a thin roll on colour, and both can be described as an epoxy floor.
How long the rebuild takes
A strip and rebuild is longer than a fresh floor and it is worth planning for realistically.
A standard two car garage on bare concrete is a two day job. The same garage with a failed coating on it is usually two and a half to three, because the removal stage is genuinely slow and because there is nearly always repair work hiding underneath that needs doing once the surface is off.
You can walk on it the evening the topcoat goes down, put boxes and shelving back the following day, and park on it after about three days. That last one is worth respecting. A hot tyre on a system that has not fully hardened is one of the few ways to mark a brand new floor, and it is a completely avoidable one.
Winter is often the easier season to book an interior rebuild, because our exterior calendar is closed and a heated or closed garage holds plenty of temperature to cure the system.
The one thing worth doing before we arrive
Clear the floor completely. Everything, including the things that live in the corners and have not moved in years.
It sounds obvious and it is the single biggest cause of a job taking longer than quoted. A slab cannot be ground in patches around obstacles, because the ground and unground areas will not accept the coating the same way and the join will show. Everything has to come out, which usually means the driveway under a tarpaulin or a neighbour garage for two days.
While it is out, it is worth deciding what actually goes back in. A surprising number of customers use the two days as an excuse to get rid of half of it, and then discover the room they thought they needed a coating to fix was mostly a storage problem.
If it is still under warranty somewhere
Before you pay anybody to redo a floor that failed early, spend twenty minutes finding out whether somebody else already owes you one.
Dig out the original paperwork. A professional installation should have come with written terms, and a system that lifted within a couple of years is exactly what those terms exist for. Photograph the failure now, while it is at its worst, and note the date it first appeared.
If it was a kit you applied yourself, the manufacturer warranty almost certainly covers material rather than labour or preparation, which means it is worth very little in practice. That is not a trick, it is simply what those products are.
And if the original contractor has stopped answering the phone, which happens more than it should, that tells you something useful about what the next quote should be judged on. Ask how long the company has been trading and who actually turns up.
Had one fail already
Send a photograph of the worst area and roughly when it was done. Jimmy can usually tell you which of the three failure modes you are looking at before he even comes out, and what a proper rebuild would involve.
Call (484) 942-3219 or email jfaust@cobraepoxy.com.
Book a walkthrough